Orr v. American Family Insurance Company, S.I

Court

District Court, E.D. Missouri (E.D. Mo.)
Official Court Website →

Assigned judge

Abbie Crites-Leoni · 84 cases in index

Docket number

4:25-cv-01500

Cause

28:1332 Diversity-Insurance Contract
28 U.S.C. § 1332 — Diversity jurisdiction

Nature of suit

110 Insurance
Disputes over an insurance policy — denial of a claim, the scope of coverage, or an insurer's alleged bad-faith handling.

Jurisdiction

Diversity

Jury demand

Defendant

Date filed

10/06/2025

8,212 Contract cases in this court are indexed here.

Parties

• plaintiff · Orr · 578 cases
• defendant · American Family Insurance Company, S.I · 8 cases

Part of a Larger Litigation Pattern

This is one of 9 Contract cases in our index naming American Family Insurance Company, S.I — a possible mass-tort or coordinated-litigation cluster.

• Mueller v. American Family Insurance Company, S.I
  District Court, D. ColoradoFiled 10/10/2025
• Ryals v. American Family Insurance Company, S.I
  District Court, D. ColoradoFiled 09/09/2020
• Andrews v. American Family Insurance Company, S.I
  District Court, D. ColoradoFiled 09/02/2019
• American Family Insurance Company S.I v. Debibar
  District Court, D. ArizonaFiled 07/25/2019
• American Family Insurance Company, S.I v. Pinson
  District Court, E.D. MissouriFiled 03/13/2018
• Acp Storm Repair, LLC v. American Family Insurance Company, S.I
  District Court, D. ColoradoFiled 09/06/2017

About Contract Lawsuits

Contract lawsuits involve disputes over an agreement between parties — claims that one side failed to perform, breached a term, or owes money under a contract. Common examples include unpaid invoices, broken business deals, and warranty or insurance disputes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Orr v. American Family Insurance Company, S.I?

Orr v. American Family Insurance Company, S.I is a federal contract lawsuit filed on 10/06/2025 in the District Court, E.D. Missouri. The case is currently open in the federal court system. Contract lawsuits involve disputes over an agreement between parties — claims that one side failed to perform, breached a term, or owes money under a contract. Common examples include unpaid invoices, broken business deals, and warranty or insurance disputes.

What type of case is this?

It is classified as “Contract” under the federal nature-of-suit system. Contract lawsuits involve disputes over an agreement between parties — claims that one side failed to perform, breached a term, or owes money under a contract. Common examples include unpaid invoices, broken business deals, and warranty or insurance disputes.

What court is the case in?

The case is in the District Court, E.D. Missouri, docket number 4:25-cv-01500.

When was the case filed?

Orr v. American Family Insurance Company, S.I was filed on 10/06/2025. The case is currently open.

What law is the case brought under?

The docket lists the cause as 28 U.S.C. § 1332 — Diversity jurisdiction.